Quote Originally Posted by duhvoodooman
My concern re: the Lil Puncher and other rail-type pickups is that I'll lose too much of the essential Tele character, which I don't want to sacrifice too much of. I'm not looking to make the bridge sound like a 'bucker or even a P90. I still want that Tele single coil character, but with a bit less twang and a bit more girth.
No worries there. I have the "Modern Vintage" 10K Lil Puncher bridge p'up, and it has spank to spare. I have it tapped, but find I don't use the single coil tone much at all, even for chickin'-pickin'. I think the Tele bridge/saddle combo contributes as much or more to the "spank" than the p'up does.

It will grind when pumped through a good OD or Distortion pedal, and I imagine it will push the front end of a tube amp a bit more than a single coil, but it's still far spankier than the bridge p'ups in either of my humbucker equipped guitars.