Yes, he's a great player of anything, not just LP's.......that being said (I have 4 Bonamassa CD's; A New Day Yesterday; So It's Like That; Blues Deluxe and Had To Cry Today), I think he's at a point (how to say this ??? ) where he has to either go for a distinctive tone or to be a king of pyrotechnic guitar playing. This isn't a knock on JB, he can flat out play.....but to me he doesn't have a signature tone that screams JB.
As to LP players, like Duane and Leslie West, or non-LP players like Albert King, Bonnie Raitt or Santana....you hear a tune and say to yourself, well if it isn't them, it sure sounds like their playing. I don't see Joe that way YET. Maybe he needs a DVM pedal or 3 to put him over the top. :
However, as a technician, who can flat out burn the strings; ala Vai or Satriani; he's up in that league. :