I guess by tones I use the same basic set up on my pedals, but I change amps back and forth.
I have an array of pedals mostly Fulltone. I have a Radial Tonebone that has an actual 12ax7 tube in it for some really cool distortion. DD20 for any kind of delay I want in the effects loop. My Fulldrive II, OCD, and Fat boost are all used individually or in tandem. I also have a mini deja vibe for trem and chorus. I have all of them set and do not touch the controls. All of my amps have spring reverb set on 5 or 6. My amps are mostly on clean and mid volume. I rarely play "naked" without pedals.
One of the factors is that I only play at home. To get my amps to the break up point I would be way too loud, so I "simulate" it with pedals. But 5 or 6 on a 40 Watt Marshall is plenty loud. I have a Cry Baby but rarely use it. I have just about every pickup combo covered with my guitars so I jump back and forth between my 2 Marshalls, 65 Deluxe reverb and my Blues Junior Special edition amps.
The Blues is alright!
Guitars: 1968 Gibson SG, 2005 Gibson SG Standard, 2006 Gibson LP Classic Gold top, 2004 Epiphone Elitist LP Custom, 1996 Gibson Les Paul Standard. 2001 Epiphone Sheraton II, 2007 Epiphone G400.
Fender Strats: 1996 Fender 68 Reissue CIJ, 2008 Squier CV 50s, 2009 Squier CV 50s Tele Butterescotch Blonde
Amps: Blues Junior Special edition Jensen in Brown Tolex with Wheat front, 65 Deluxe Reverb reissue,1970 Sonax reverb by Traynor, Avatar Custom 2/12 Cabinet with Eminence Legend V1216 speakers,
2008 DSL100 Marshall Amp , Fender Super Champ XD,Fender Vibro Champ XD
Effects and Pedals: Fulltone Fulldrive II, Fulltone OCD, Fulltone Mini Deja Vibe, Fulltone Fat Boost, Dunlop Crybaby Wah, Boss DS1, Boss DD20 Giga Delay, Boss TU2 tuner, Boss BD2, Ibanez TS9 Tube screamer, Zoom 505. Radial tonebone hot british.