Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 19 of 34

Thread: Why aren't guitarists happy with their tones?

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    Finland
    Posts
    3,424
    Post Thanks / Like
    Blog Entries
    23

    Default Why aren't guitarists happy with their tones?

    It seems to me, no matter what gear, pretty much every guitarist keeps changing their tones all the time. Usually gear too, to achieve that end.

    Why is it that we strive for some 'gold standard' which is nothing but make-believe _on record_ and not what you would get playing that studio rig live?

    I'll say this much: I believe I have better or as good a tone out of my gear as _anybody_ ever did. And I mean NOBODY ever, any artist, got better tones (for the type of tone of course).

    Now, that's what _I_ think. You may not think my tone the greatest. But why don't you make your tone what YOU want it to be, instead of striving to get 'the tone he and he got on that album' etc.

    I admit it, I cannot record my tone as well as I'd like. I don't have a multimillion studio or production crew and mixing wizards to use. Thus I do hear tones on record that are better than what I get on record. But not hugely better. I'm sure my sound is as good as they were in the studio.

    Besides, tones are always per song. Money For Nothing may have a great tone to guitar, but it can't be used for many a song.

    Then there are some artists who never change their basic tone...Angus and Neil Young have never changed their gear and tone throughout their career - they sound completely different on each album, because the studio and producers were different.

    Why do people fall into the trap of trying to achieve with gear changes, what actually is like 48% studio magic and 48% in your fingers and mere few percent to do with the gear used?

    Let's discuss!
    Dee

    "When life's a biatch, be a horny dog"

    Amps: Marshall JVM 410H w/ Plexi Cap mod, Choke Mod & Negative Feedback Removal mod, 4x12", Behringer GMX110, Amplitube 3/StealthPedal

    Half a dozen custom built/bastardized guitars all with EMG's, mostly 85's, Ibanez Artwood acoustic & Yamaha SGR bass, Epiphone Prophecy SG, Vox Wah, Pitchblack tuner plus assorted pedals, rack gear etc. for home studio use.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Location
    Sun Valley, Idaho
    Posts
    10,955
    Post Thanks / Like
    Blog Entries
    1

    Default

    I am generally happy with my tones. Not always my technique, but my tones are generally good.
    Steve Thompson
    Sun Valley, Idaho


    Guitars: Fender 60th Anniversary Std. Strat, Squier CVC Tele Hagstrom Viking Semi-hollow, Joshua beach guitar, Martin SPD-16TR Dreadnought
    Amphs: Peavey Classic 30, '61 Fender Concert
    Effects and such: Boss: DS-1, CE-5, NS-2 and RC20XL looper, Digitech Bad Monkey, Korg AX1G Multi-effects, Berhinger: TU100 tuner, PB100 Clean Boost, Line 6 Toneport UX2, Electro Harmonix Little Big Muff Pi, DuhVoodooMan's Rabid Rodent Rat Clone, Zonkin Yellow Screamer Mk. II, MXR Carbon Copy Delay


    love is the answer, at least for most of the questions in my heart. . .
    - j. johnson

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Clear Lake, Texas
    Posts
    5,413
    Post Thanks / Like
    Blog Entries
    1

    Default

    I'm very pleased with my quiver of tones, be it guitar > cable > Egnater Tweaker,
    or guitar > HD500 > Tweaker. The HD500 is a GAS killer.
    I've D/L'ed HD500 user's patches and adjusted them to my ear, so there is little else I want or need.

    That said, I'd like to get a Fender Mustang to be my second amp to split dual signal to, and a Tele for variety.

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    MSP
    Posts
    3,913
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    Honestly? I think it's because listening to music is what inspires guitarists to play in the first place. Where do you hear that music? From albums. You want to sound like that.

    Your point is a good one, but it's not one that's particularly obvious to somebody who doesn't have a lot of experience playing and recording. I tend to think that guitar playing brings out the analytical side in a lot of people, and they want to know what each type of amp does for you and your sound/playing/etc. Enough is never enough, because there's always some new technology coming out that might change everything (e.g. AxeFX or modeling in general).

    There's a point at which your tone is so bad that it makes you hate the electric guitar. Similarly, there's a point at which your tone is so good it makes you love the guitar. I think people always want to get as close to the latter as possible, hence the unending gear hunt.

    Lastly, I don't think everyone picks a tone and sticks with it for their entire life. Many people change styles, which leads to another huge hunt. It's very similar to how everyone feels the need to be everything and to be the best at it.
    Quote Originally Posted by Spudman
    Does anyone read the original post?
    Guitars: Gibson LP Studio, MIA Fender Precision, Carvin C350
    Amps: Genz Benz Shuttle 6.0 + Avatar B212 / Genzler 12-3, Acoustic B20
    Pedals: Pod HD500X, Diamond Compressor, Tech 21 VT Bass, Sonic Research Turbo Tuner

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    MSP
    Posts
    3,913
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    BTW Dee, watch this turn into a I-don't-know-what-you're-talking-about-I-love-my-tone-I'm-not-insecure thread. I could be wrong, but your initial post makes me think that's the fate of this thread.
    Quote Originally Posted by Spudman
    Does anyone read the original post?
    Guitars: Gibson LP Studio, MIA Fender Precision, Carvin C350
    Amps: Genz Benz Shuttle 6.0 + Avatar B212 / Genzler 12-3, Acoustic B20
    Pedals: Pod HD500X, Diamond Compressor, Tech 21 VT Bass, Sonic Research Turbo Tuner

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    Finland
    Posts
    3,424
    Post Thanks / Like
    Blog Entries
    23

    Default

    Lol I hope not, Eric...well you raise an interesting point. Does everyone go thru the same phases?

    For me, the first 5 years or so I played, it was just a matter of getting gear that would do the job. Never had money to buy what I wanted, but not that keen on achieving any particular sound. Just the best I could with what I had.

    Then another 5 years or more, didn't have the time to bother searching for tones; just gigged almost like working etc. and didn't really change my gear in a decade.

    It was really only after I stopped gigging and mainly just played home that I became obsessed with sounds and tried dozen amps and guitars nd pickups...and only in recent years have finally gotten to a point I know how to get just the sound I want with many different gear pieces or amps even. I used to think I was late to find my niche but of late it seems it's quite the opposite for many people.
    Dee

    "When life's a biatch, be a horny dog"

    Amps: Marshall JVM 410H w/ Plexi Cap mod, Choke Mod & Negative Feedback Removal mod, 4x12", Behringer GMX110, Amplitube 3/StealthPedal

    Half a dozen custom built/bastardized guitars all with EMG's, mostly 85's, Ibanez Artwood acoustic & Yamaha SGR bass, Epiphone Prophecy SG, Vox Wah, Pitchblack tuner plus assorted pedals, rack gear etc. for home studio use.

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Location
    Sun Valley, Idaho
    Posts
    10,955
    Post Thanks / Like
    Blog Entries
    1

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Eric View Post
    BTW Dee, watch this turn into a I-don't-know-what-you're-talking-about-I-love-my-tone-I'm-not-insecure thread. I could be wrong, but your initial post makes me think that's the fate of this thread.

    LOL! Eric, you nailed me. I did start it out that way. But it's true for me! Re: why others do what they do, a common objection made in court is against testimony that is speculative, particularly if it is speculation about what is in the mind of another. I can't help but think that way because that is how I was trained. But setting legal style logic aside, i could guess at others' motivations. One could be that it is easier to mess around with gear, talk about gear, etc., than to work on your own technique and sounds given what you have. Another would be that your mind hears something in music you hear that you don't find right away in your own gear, so you go looking.
    Steve Thompson
    Sun Valley, Idaho


    Guitars: Fender 60th Anniversary Std. Strat, Squier CVC Tele Hagstrom Viking Semi-hollow, Joshua beach guitar, Martin SPD-16TR Dreadnought
    Amphs: Peavey Classic 30, '61 Fender Concert
    Effects and such: Boss: DS-1, CE-5, NS-2 and RC20XL looper, Digitech Bad Monkey, Korg AX1G Multi-effects, Berhinger: TU100 tuner, PB100 Clean Boost, Line 6 Toneport UX2, Electro Harmonix Little Big Muff Pi, DuhVoodooMan's Rabid Rodent Rat Clone, Zonkin Yellow Screamer Mk. II, MXR Carbon Copy Delay


    love is the answer, at least for most of the questions in my heart. . .
    - j. johnson

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    3,298
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    Yeah, Eric's a pretty honest guy who gives away the weakest point of every guitarist. Bassists never suffer from the I-hate-my-tone syndrome. But honestly after more than 20 years I got my nice tones together and made a huge improve with the purchase of my JTM45 and my OCD pedal. There is only one tone that I still haven't reached, it's the Eric Gales kinda Strat grit tone, hollow woody sounding...you know what I'm talking about. Overall I had times where I was on the tone quest, but somehow I have reached a good point in my search. Eric, you are absolutely right with the fact that our imagination of good tone changes with the music we listen to.
    "A lot of people in the industry want to blame downloading for the state of the business. But I think if most music wasn't shit to begin with people wouldn't be downloading it for free," - Corey Taylor (Slipknot)

  9. #9
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Posts
    5,018
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Jimi75 View Post
    Bassists never suffer from the I-hate-my-tone syndrome.
    Ha! I know a bass player you should meet who obsesses over his tone like... well like the guitarists Dee was describing.

    Eric's answer is pretty much how I see it as well, particularly with the bit about being analytical. My personal quest for tone isn't necessarily to find the tones guitarists I admire used because I want to sound like them when I play. It's more about trying to figure out how they did it so I have a better understanding of what effects/settings make which sounds. It's a nice "a-ha!" moment when I stumble upon a setting that sounds like something I know. Mostly, I'm just addicted to tone.
    "I happen to have perfect situational awareness, Lana. Which cannot be taught, by the way. Like a poet's ... mind for ... to make the perfect words." - Sterling Archer

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Feb 2011
    Location
    Texas
    Posts
    35
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    For me it's about trying to find that tone I hear in my head. With relatively little experience on six string, I haven't gotten enough gear time to know what will give me which tone.

    So it's try this and try that until I get more knowledge under my belt.

  11. #11
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Plymouth, MA USA
    Posts
    2,077
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    I have decided that most of tone is in the hands - and fingers - of the player and only to a smaller extent to the gear. Robert is a great example that I have seen with other pro level players - they can play on what many of us would consider 'lesser grade' - and even 'low-end' gear (see/hear Robert on the $50. Fullerton strat, or any of his Squiers) - his tone is pretty damn good on all of it, and if you didn't KNOW that he was playing 'lesser' gear there, I doubt that you would ever guess it. So I have also decided that if I want good tone, I need to shop less and play more - and I mean play the guitar, not play around with more gear. I am, little by little more pleased with the tones I am getting, and look forward to developing better skills to better my tone.
    "GAS never sleeps" - Gil Janus

    "Now you got to pay your dues. Get that axe and play the blues." - Spudman

    Gear: Epiphone Sheraton II, Epiphone Wildkat, Epiphone Emperor Joe Pass, Fender MIM Strat, Tacoma DR-14, Johnson JR-200 resonator; Fender Super Champ XD amp

  12. #12
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Clear Lake, Texas
    Posts
    5,413
    Post Thanks / Like
    Blog Entries
    1

    Default

    Maybe it is because every other gear ad has the marketing bonus word "tone" in it?
    It will make you drop your magazine subscriptions!

  13. #13
    Join Date
    Jan 2011
    Posts
    31
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by tjcurtin1 View Post
    I have decided that most of tone is in the hands - and fingers - of the player and only to a smaller extent to the gear. Robert is a great example that I have seen with other pro level players - they can play on what many of us would consider 'lesser grade' - and even 'low-end' gear (see/hear Robert on the $50. Fullerton strat, or any of his Squiers) - his tone is pretty damn good on all of it, and if you didn't KNOW that he was playing 'lesser' gear there, I doubt that you would ever guess it. So I have also decided that if I want good tone, I need to shop less and play more - and I mean play the guitar, not play around with more gear. I am, little by little more pleased with the tones I am getting, and look forward to developing better skills to better my tone.
    This. About 2 years ago when I started playing in a band again seriously myself and the other guitarist went amp shopping, as we both needed amps with a little more kick than what we had. We tried a lot of different stuff, different brands, different types of amp (tube, solid state, hybrid, digital whatever) And although we both found something we liked in the end, a horrible truth dawned on me during the testing process: It's me. It's not the amp, guitar or anything else. It's me. And guess what? I spent a little more time practicing and improving my technique and sure enough my tone improved. I think that's the root of the problem, we go chasing awesome sounds and tones that we hear on records or at gigs or whatever and think the secret is in the gear, and forget that at the end of the day it sounds that way because of the guy (or girl) who's playing it. That being said I'm a complete hypocrite who's GASing for an Engl Special Edition so I can sound like this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n7FgjfcKuuo
    My gear:

    Jackson RR3
    ESP/LTD M-200 - For Sale PM for details
    Monterey Stage Series Strat copy

    Ibanez TBX150H Head + Cab

    Like melodic, groovy metal? Check out my band Trinatyde on facebook/myspace

  14. #14
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    Finland
    Posts
    3,424
    Post Thanks / Like
    Blog Entries
    23

    Default

    Yes I think there is the key. As long as the gear is in the ballpark - like an active bucker and at least somewhat marshally-able amp for me - I can get a nice enough tone. Ultimately it's more about how than what you play.

    But, coveting for amps is no different from coveting a ferrari for instance - it's fun even purely aesthetically, let alone other niceties. It's feeling good to have gotten out of the endless search for perfect gear, but equally nice to own and use nice new gear too.
    Dee

    "When life's a biatch, be a horny dog"

    Amps: Marshall JVM 410H w/ Plexi Cap mod, Choke Mod & Negative Feedback Removal mod, 4x12", Behringer GMX110, Amplitube 3/StealthPedal

    Half a dozen custom built/bastardized guitars all with EMG's, mostly 85's, Ibanez Artwood acoustic & Yamaha SGR bass, Epiphone Prophecy SG, Vox Wah, Pitchblack tuner plus assorted pedals, rack gear etc. for home studio use.

  15. #15
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    3,298
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    I also believe that good tone is somehow in the fingers. Some guys have it , some not. In this thread though I understood tone being the tone that a certain equipment can produce. To me my Marshall plus my OCD produces a certain creamy, bluesy tone, in the end it's "in my fingers" what I make out of it, but the ingredients are set.
    "A lot of people in the industry want to blame downloading for the state of the business. But I think if most music wasn't shit to begin with people wouldn't be downloading it for free," - Corey Taylor (Slipknot)

  16. #16
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    NW Missouri,
    Posts
    4,097
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    Why aren't guitarists happy with their tones?

    I think everyone's touched on some very good points here.
    Personally, I'd say I like my sound, tone, whatever.......most......of the time.

    When I can't get a setting or sound that's quite right, I'm bored with my playing, and I need to learn something new. I'm in a rut and no amount of equipment change or adjustment is going to supply that elusive missing ingredient.
    I agree that what's going on with the fingers makes a difference. Sometimes it can be as simple as not overplaying, playing a lick or phrase differently than you're used to, or substituting a chord for one you usually play.

    I've gone through periods where I thought a better tone was just a new guitar/amph/effect away from what I had. I found out if the gear you have is quality and you know how to use it, that's good enough.
    Another factor is what tone you're after to start with. Albert Collins and Jimi Hendrix were both blues based players, but it takes more gear to get Jimi's sounds, with the octaver, uni-vibe, fuzz, and other stuff he had going on. They were both great players, but had uniquely different tone from their gear. I can imagine the frustration if, after years of practicing, playing, and getting Jimi's sound down, I heard Albert's playing and wanted to get his sound.........it'd be back to the drawing board, and "I'm not happy with my tone!"
    Guitars
    Wilburn Versatare, '52 FrankenTele(Fender licensed parts), Fender USA Roadhouse Strat, Fender USA Standard B-bender Telecaster, Agile AL 3000 w/ WCR pickups, Ibanez MIJ V300 Acoustic, Squier Precision Bass,
    Amps
    Ceriatone Overtone Special, Musicman 212 Sixty-Five, Fender Blues Jr., Peavey Classic 30, Fender Super Reverb, Traynor YCV-40 WR Anniversary w/ matching 1x12 ext. cab, Epiphone SoCal 50w head w/ matching 4x12 cab (Lady Luck speakers), Avatar 2x12 semi-open back cab w/ Celestion speakers
    Pedals
    Digitech Bad Monkey, Digitech Jamman, DVM's ZYS, Goodrich volume pedal

  17. #17
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Clear Lake, Texas
    Posts
    5,413
    Post Thanks / Like
    Blog Entries
    1

    Default

    I guess I see things a little differently... While there is certainly overlap, I think "technique" gets labeled "tone" too often. I don't mean style or skill, but actual touch (I know, they intermingle). Sure tone starts in how we pluck, strum, pick, mute, and play the strings,
    but I like to separate tone more into the many components that shape it, such as:
    potentiometers, string gauge/material, bridge design, nut, capacitors, pickups, body/neck wood, effects, amps, and speakers, etc...

    Technique and tone are such huge areas, they deserve their own distinction when warranted.

    Just sayin'...

  18. #18
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Location
    High & Dry, Southern California
    Posts
    1,483
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    There's something to it in all of the above posts, but I believe heavily in the 'it's in the hands - technique with both of them - camp, and application of those techniques befitting the combination of gear & settings. It's a symbiotic relationship, a sum of the parts, no single thing.

    OTH, tinnitus (sp?) caused by standing in front of a dimed 500 watt Double Stack of 4x12's for 3 hours a night 3 or 4 or 5 nights a week could have something to do with hating your tone....
    ^^
    AXES: Fender '81 The STRAT, '12 Standard Tele, '78 Musicmaster Bass, '13 CN-240SCE Thinline; Rickenbacker '82 360-12BWB; Epiphone '05 Casino, '08 John Lennon EJ-160E; Guild '70 D-40NT; Ovation '99 Celebrity CS-257; Yamaha '96 FG411CE-12; Washburn '05 M6SW Mando, '08 Oscar Schmidt OU250Bell Uke; Johnson '96 JR-200-SB Squareneck Reso; Hofner '07 Icon B-Bass; Ibanez '12 AR-325. AMPS: Tech 21 Trademark 10; Peavey ValveKing Royal 8; Fender Acoustonic 90, Passport Mini, Mini Tonemaster; Marshall MS-2 Micro Stack; Behringer BX-108 Thunderbird; Tom Scholz Rockman. PEDALS/FX: Boss ME-50; Yamaha EMP100; Stage DE-1; Samson C-Com 16 L.R. Baggs ParaAcoustic D.I; MXR EQ-10.

  19. #19
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    7,260
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Jimi75 View Post
    Yeah, Eric's a pretty honest guy who gives away the weakest point of every guitarist. Bassists never suffer from the I-hate-my-tone syndrome.
    In general, I believe you are correct about bassists. However, tour the TalkBass forums sometime and you'll think differently. Back when I was playing, other than slobbering over a high-end Spector, I could have plugged my Peavey P-Bass into my Peavey combo and let 'er rip for the rest of my life.

    For me personally, it was just figuring out who I am as a guitar player. As much as I admire SRV, I really don't want to play like him. Took me a long time to figure that out. I'd much rather play like my other main hero, George Lynch. Even at that, though, it's more of a general thing rather than an "I will imitate him in every aspect of everything" thing. Since I've gotten my Dinky and my Jet City I've been consistently happy with how I sound. Now it's a matter of getting my chops up to snuff.

    Part of the reason, I'm sure, is because there is new cool stuff coming out all the time. Someone who is really into playing is going to want to try this stuff out. Lynch seems to have this perfectionist quality to him when it comes to tone. The problem is I don't think he really knows what "perfection" is or if it even really exists. I would describe that more as a neurosis than anything else. Really creative people do have this tendency to be nuttier than hoot owls. Of course, pro players who make it big have the wherewithal to fund gear acquisitions.
    Axen: Jackson DK2M, Fender Deluxe Nashville Telecaster, Reverend Warhawk 390, Taylor 914ce, ESP LTD Surveyor-414
    Amphen: Jet City JCA22H and JCA12S cab, Carvin X-60 combo, Acoustic B20
    Effecten: "Thesis 96" Overdrive/Boost (aka DVM OD2), Hardwire DL-8 Digital Delay/Looper, DigiTech Polara Reverb, DigiTech EX-7 Expression Factory and CF-7 Chorus Factory, Danelectro CF-1 Cool Cat Fuzz
    "I wish Imagine Dragons would be stuck in an Arcade Fire for an entire Vampire Weekend."--Brian Posehn

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •