I like the tweed tones of old Fenders. I like that Marshall sound too, but somehow the Fender Tweed sound seems a bit more ragged or something. Looking at a Catalinbread Formula No. 5 (made to model a 5E3 circuit) or the 5F6, made to model the older earlier 50's tweeds.

Here is a pretty fun video comparing them, along with a couple others. I tend to like the Formula No. 5 in this video, though I also like that SFT.

Recall that I also have @duhvoodooman 's Rabid Rodent. But I think it tends to get more of a late '70s/80's rock tone rather than a tweed tone.

Thoughts?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uoBNANbhEfo


And this one focusing more on the Formula No. 5 and using the guitar volume knob to control it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kGhoZHGm7KQ