Wow Warren, this is one of the reasons that I no longer post to that forum!
Just for the record, I am left-handed. When I first decided to take up the guitar, at the tender age of 37 or so, the advice my friend gave to me made much sense.
My friend told me that I could go either way, but that I would find a greater variety of instruments made in the "right-handed" mold. He then went on to speak about what the two hands do in playing the guitar, noting that the most intricate work (fretting notes in a scale) seemed to be done by the most ill-equipped hand of most guitarists. In the end, I chose to go the "right-handed" route, and I haven't looked back since, except to think about all those poor lefties out there who either can't find the instrument they want in a "left-handed" version, or that pay a left-handed "tax" of a premium price for the different version.
Tonight, I just closed a deal for a very nice, expensive bass, and that deal would never have happened if I had chosen to play "left-handed." In fact, I wouldn't own the guitar I am trading for that bass if I hadn't decided to step into the "right-handed" world of guitar!
Now, that said, Bob Rogers did make sense when he recommended that the child should be given a guitar to hold and see which way they naturally hold it. Unfortunately, he let his sensitivity as an individual who lives life with "the hand of the Devil" get in the way of a civil discussion, and it seemed to cloud his view.
L8TR,
Rob Smith
I AM the bass player!
GUITARS: '93 ZON Sonus 4, '85 G&L L-2000 (Mahogany), '05 Schecter Stiletto Custom 4, '06 SX SJB-62MG (Fretless), '07 Squier Bronco (project), '06 Ibanez AEB10E-BK acoustic bass, '70s Epiphone OO-sized acoustic, '94 Peavey Reactor (extreme makeover edition)
AMPS: '03 Ampeg BA115 bass combo, '86 Peavey MkIV Series 400 bass head, SWR Workingman's cabs, 2x10" & 1x15", '00 Peavey Micro Bass