I am in the camp of share what ya want, but buy what you use.
This is just taking us back to tape decks and all the cries back then.
Musicians know if their music is not heard, people will not buy it.
Radios/TV promote music that is "pushed" and these days it seems more and more limited.
I see no difference in taping a radio or a television broadcast.
I think every record company should have a download site with 'fair" prices for all their artists.
It would end alot of the problems, while promoting other artists in their barn.
I think ALL artists should have their OWN site with downloads available.
People who copy will do so if not on the net, then through radio etc.
And yes, the quality is there to with the devices we have available.

Pirates: Mass share, and mass produce and sell!
I really question the Judge that decided for the record industry.
Limewire did not HOLD any songs and was just a media for sharing.
it was up to the "user" of the site to share what they had.
I use the web as I do a radio or a Television.
My cable even comes with recording capabilites.
You can buy recording products everyplace.
I assume the judge should give them a stop order too.
In the end, If I like it, I hit Amazon etc. and buy it.