Matt,

I think any of those you mentioned would work. The Digitech has over 4 seconds of delay, although I can't imagine needing it. I like the dual outs if I'm running two amps. That's the one I mentioned because it's the one I have used. I previously had a Danelectro PB &J. I wouldn't recommend that unless you trust plastic cases and just need a slapback thing. I sold mine cheap when I bought the Digitech.

The Carbon Copy is analog, so it might be a better sounding delay, depending on how good your hearing is. I doubt I could hear the difference, but I'm 60 and have tinnitus.....they always seem to get good reviews, though. Some guys swear by analog if it's a delay pedal.

TC electronics have had a good reputation and gotten good reviews for years, that's about all I know about them. I doubt I'd use the toneprint feature, but that's just me.

I'll just throw this out there if you're on a budget....... a lot of people really seem to like the Modtone pedals. I have no experience with them.