Deeaa,

I see what you're saying and agree with you that the bass isn't very important in a hard rock/heavy metal context. In that genre, the bass can be inaudible.

I don't play metal though. Maybe it's for that reason that I rarely even listen to metal anymore.

From my perspective and my own opinion, in playing other less guitar-focused, music, bass is important. If I can't be heard clearly, then my presence or absence doesn't matter.

Think of what R&B, funk, soul, jazz and so on would be without a strong bass line to move the music along. I don't think you could have easily replaced James Jamerson and gotten the Motown that you hear today.

The simple fact is, there are a whole lot of nice and creative baselines in popular music where the bass player makes a huge difference. If you have some time on your hands, I can begin reciting examples...

Going back to your first point though, no I wouldn't play with Bonamossa, Hendrix, etc. unless I were being paid hansomely to destroy my hearing.

For my part, and in my opinion, everyone should be heard clearly in a band. It's my belief that the best music is made where everyone has an equal contribution.

BTW - I don't take any offense to your posting. I happen to have a fairly different musical perspective.